Sunday, February 8, 2009

About the polls conducted by the Library

First of all, I want to thank the gentleman that left this comment. I welcome the opportunity to answer your questions and address concerns. As a librarian, giving good information in a timely fashion is what I do!

Here was the comment:
"It's one thing that ask if the Libary Expansion should go on ballot but another to vote in favor of the tax increase. These are separate questions that should be asked in all your polling. If you can not get above 50% on the poll to vote in favor there is no sense to have this on the ballot - because it will fail. I would rather not to have the north branch and concentrate solely on the expansion of the downtown facility."

Unfortunately, the Library cannot use taxpayer dollars on a poll that asks directly for support on a ballot measure. The Board considered exactly that poll and were advised by legal counsel that they could not ask that question. The poll question used was the best information they could get using taxpayer money to determine if it was still appropriate to proceed with placing the question on the ballot in April.

The downtown facility's size is constrained by site and zoning. 70,000 sq ft of library space is the maximum facility size. But that would only meet today's need, with no space for any future growth. The proposed north side branch allows for growth for 12-15 years.

Because libraries generally build about once every 20 years (not only is that the "life expectancy" of a public building, it is also the standard length of municipal bonds), that planning horizon (2010-2030) was the focus of the planning process over the last 2 1/2 years. The Board of Trustees scaled back the plan from the 134,000 sq ft needed by 2030 to the 100,000 sq ft total included in the expansion plan today. Their goal in this was to balance today's need and future growth in an affordable plan.

Leave comments. Ask questions. I will respond.

Monday, February 2, 2009

Why is this question different?

One online comment about a recent news article on the Plainfield Public Library referendum said: "New Lenox built this great big ridiculous library, state of the art facility. A year later they were trying to get a referendum passed to pay the bills! They couldn't afford to run it!"

I'd like to respond to how the Plainfield Library's expansion plan will prevent what happened at New Lenox from happening here.

This is, unfortunately, not uncommon to libraries in Illinois. Bonds referenda pass, while the operating rate for that same project does not. It happened right here in Plainfield in the early 90's. The building bond passed in 1990. At the time, the Board of Trustees chose to wait until the new building opened to place the operating rate referendum on the ballot. The operating rate failed in 1993. The Library could no longer operate the larger building on the same budget. The Library's hours were reduced, staff laid off, and book budget frozen. Only the beginning of the population explosion relieved the operating fund deficit for the library.

With that lesson, reinforced by the New Lenox's situation, the current Board of Trustees placed both construction and operations in a single ballot question. Using a different type of bonds for the project (Alternate Revenue Bonds) allows for the single question. However, the question itself is confusing. Here is the text:

Shall the limiting rate under the Property Tax Extension Limitation Law for the Plainfield Public Library District, Will and Kendall Counties, Illinois, be increased by an additional amount equal to .1926% above the limiting rate for levy year 2007 and be equal to .3301% of the equalized assessed value of the taxable property therein for levy year 2009?

(1) The approximate amount of taxes extendable at the most recently extended limiting rate is $2,894,350, and the approximate amount of taxes extendable if the proposition is approved is $6,948,545.
(2) For the 2009 levy year the approximate amount of the additional tax extendable against property containing a single family residence and having a fair market value at the time of the referendum of $100,000 is estimated to be $64.20.
(3) If the proposition is approved, the aggregate extension for 2009 will be determined by the limiting rate set forth in the proposition, rather than the otherwise applicable limiting rate calculated under the provisions of the Property Tax Extension Limitation Law (commonly known as the Property Tax Cap Law).


What the heck does that mean? Why do you not even find the name of the library until the second line? Well, because Illinois law dictates the wording of the question. The Library fills in the blanks, with no room for clarification. The Library Board and staff are working get information out to the community to ensure that you understand the question as it will appear on the ballot - because it does not tell you "building AND operations". It does not say "quadruple the space, double the services, books, and staff, and room to grow for 12-15 years." It says a bunch of legalese about the "Property Tax Extension Limitation Law." Heck, #3 basically says if it passes the Library gets the money just as the requested. How redundant is that?

The short version of what the Library is asking: "May the Plainfield Library collect a tax rate that will both build and operate expanded facilities that will meet the needs of today with room to grow for 12-15 years?"

Tuesday, January 27, 2009

Library Expansion Plan on April 2009 Ballot

The Plainfield Public Library District Board of Trustees voted on Monday, January 26th to place the Library’s expansion plan referendum on the April 7th ballot. Referring to polls of registered voters in July, December, and January, each with over 60% support placing the referendum on the ballot in April, Board President Sharon Kinley said, “This decision is not lightly made. We’ve polled our district three times. Every computer [at the library] is filled tonight. The need is great and now it’s up to the community.”

Casting the lone dissenting vote on the ordinance to place the referendum on the April ballot, Library Board Vice President Chris Awalt said, “You want to serve the community. The polls say yes to put it on [the ballot], but it is still a difficult decision.” Awalt cited the timing of the referendum as the reason for his dissenting vote. Following the vote, he said, “We’ve got to move forward.”

Trustee Dr. Patricia Miller asked, “If we wait a year [to place it on the ballot], do we let our voters down by not doing what the community wants? We don’t know what will come in a year. All we can do is let the community decide, let the voters decide.”

Trustee Rick Martin agreed. “We put it all together, now it’s time to let the people decide.”

So now it will be up to you, the voters. A citizens committee in support of the referendum has already formed and will hold their second meeting tonight at 7pm in the Library Storytime Room.

A Facts and Figures information sheet is available with answers to some common questions. Additional information will be available here and on the library's web site. Got a question that isn't answered here? Email me or call me at the library!

For an increase of $15 per month to the average homeowner, residents would enjoy four times the space and twice the services available at the Plainfield Public Library today. About $9 of the $15 per month cost would fund the construction and equipping of the new libraries, with the remaining $6 supporting operations - everything from programs to power to personnel. The $15 per month estimated increase is based on the median home value of $315,000 in the Village of Plainfield.

The expansion plan, designed to meet the needs of the community for the next 12-15 years, while being mindful of the impact on taxpayers includes:
  • 70,000 square foot library in downtown Plainfield
  • 30,000 square foot library in the north side of the district
  • Additional staff to operate the additional library
  • Increase of over 100% to the library collection: books, movies, music, and more
  • More than double the number of Internet PCs for public use
  • Increased free programming, particularly storytimes and computer classes
  • Computer classrooms in both libraries
  • More meeting space available to support local organizations and businesses
  • More cultural programs and events through partnerships with the Plainfield Park District and other organizations
  • More jobs during construction and when the new libraries open

The total cost of the planned expanded facilities and services is a tax rate increase of 0.1926%, with 0.1163% for Alternate Revenue Bonds and 0.0763% for operations. This will be offset by the maturation of the existing bonds, decreasing the library’s existing tax rate by 0.0120% in 2010. If it passes, the property tax increase will not appear on tax bills until 2010. The net increase to the library’s tax rate will be 0.1806%.

Monday, January 26, 2009

Telephone Town Hall Meeting Audio Now Available

A link to the mp3 file of the 1/21/09 telephone town hall meeting has been added to the list on the right.

The hosting company records from the moment the go-ahead to begin dialing is given, before anyone connects to the call, so please forgive the moment of silence before we begin. there were no connections yet to the call.

Enjoy!

Friday, January 23, 2009

Correction of Enterprise 1/22/09 Article

The Enterprise ran a great article by Madhu Mayer headlined "Park district books cooperation with library over expansion plan".

The first paragraph in the second column reads "The plan would mean an estimated $30 million in building bonds and a $4 million increase in the library's annual operating budget." Actually, the $4 million increase in the library's annual operating but INCLUDES the building bond payments. Approximately $2.4 million annually will pay the Alternate Revenue Bonds that will fund the construction. An estimated $1.6 million annually will be used to operate the building. Because the Library is considering a single referendum question for both construction and operations, the type of bonds being sold will be paid from the general operating fund rather than a separate building bond fund.

Thursday, January 22, 2009

Telephone Town Hall Poll: 62% Support for April 2009 Ballot

2,543 residents connected to our telephone town hall meeting last night! Thank you so much for participating. The Board of Trustees and I appreciate and value your feedback in this planning process.

435 people responded to the poll question: “Do you support or oppose putting the Library expansion plan referendum on the April 2009 ballot?”

268 people (62% of those responding) support placing the Library expansion referendum on the April 2009 ballot.

That response is consistent with December poll results, from a random sample poll of registered voters in the district, of 68% support with a margin of error of +/- 4%.

Thank you to Eve, who was unable to ask her question on the telephone town hall, but who left me a message with her question: "What is the urgency? Why can't we wait?"

The urgency is the demand for service by our community. Wait lists for books and programs are the norm, not the exception. The wait time increases each month as demand increases. The surge in public library use during recessions is well-documented (the NBC Nightly News segment on this was posted here 12/11/08).

The Library's population is 264% over the population this building was built to serve. Double digit increases, in circulation, cardholders, attendance and more, occur annually. This well-used public building will be 20 years old before any expansion would open. It will be 18-24 months from the day the Library breaks ground until a new library opens. It will be a full year from the day of the election until the increase appears on property tax bills, should the referendum pass.

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

This Just In! Schematic Deisgn of the Downtown Library

The pdf of the schematic design of the downtown library is now linked on this page!

You can view the site configuration, floor plans, and exterior elevations for the downtown library expansion. Included also are some of the exterior designs considered along the way. You'll be able to tell which are which - the selected option are color and five different views of the building.

Questions? Just ask!